Caribbean Macaroni Pie

Firm, sliceable and deeply savoury, Caribbean macaroni pie sits somewhere between baked pasta and a set cheese custard. The macaroni is coated with evaporated milk, egg, mustard, softened onion, garlic and cheddar, then baked until the top is golden and the centre holds cleanly when cut. Its appeal is in the texture: tender pasta bound together rather than loose and creamy, with a rich cheesy finish and gentle mustard sharpness. Serve it hot in squares as a vegetarian main, or alongside Caribbean stews where it soaks up sauces without falling apart.
Cuisine style Caribbean home cooking
Flavor profile Cheesy • Savoury • Gently mustardy
Techniques Boiling • Baking
Key equipment Baking dish • Oven
Cooking style Make-ahead friendly • Crowd-friendly
Time commitment Under 1 hour

Why this recipe works

  • Creamy but sliceable: Evaporated milk, egg and Cheddar bind the macaroni into a savoury custard that sets firmly without feeling dry.
  • Savoury depth: Softened onion, garlic and mustard add flavour through the pasta rather than relying on cheese alone.
  • Flexible serving: The pie can be served as a vegetarian main or cut into neat squares as a side for stews and braised dishes.

Get the most out of this recipe

Timing notes

  • Rest before slicing: Let the pie stand for the full 10 minutes after baking so the custard firms and the squares cut cleanly.
  • Best served hot: Serve once rested but still hot, when the top is golden and the centre is fully set.

Ingredient notes

  • Why evaporated milk works: Evaporated milk gives the custard body and a subtle richness without making the bake too loose.
  • Choose a good melting cheese: Cheddar gives the classic sharp, savoury flavour; a nuttier cheese such as Gruyere will make the pie more mellow.
  • Cook the pasta slightly short: Boiling the macaroni just shy of al dente helps it finish in the custard without turning soft.

Authenticity notes

  • Firm, home-style bake: Caribbean macaroni pie is typically made to set into slices rather than spoon like a loose macaroni cheese.
  • Classic pairing: Its cheesy, savoury richness works especially well alongside Caribbean stews and saucy mains.

Make-ahead tips

  • Bake ahead: Bake the pie, cool it completely, then refrigerate in a sealed container for up to 3 days.
  • Reheat slices gently: Warm slices in a 180°C (355°F) oven until piping hot, covering loosely if the top is browning too much.
  • Freeze in portions: Freeze well-wrapped slices for easy serving later, then thaw before reheating for the best texture.

Equipment you'll need

Ingredients
Instructions
Print
  1. Heat the oven to 190°C (375°F). Grease a baking dish with a little of the unsalted butter.
  2. Melt the remaining unsalted butter in a saucepan over medium heat. Add the yellow onion with a pinch of the fine sea salt and cook for 6 to 8 minutes until softened, then add the garlic and cook for 1 minute until fragrant.
  3. Bring a large pot of well-salted water to the boil and cook the macaroni until just shy of al dente, about 1 to 2 minutes less than the packet suggests. Drain well in a colander and return the pasta to the pot.
  4. Stir the onion and garlic into the macaroni. Add the evaporated milk, dijon mustard, remaining fine sea salt and black pepper, then mix until the pasta is evenly coated.
  5. In a bowl, whisk the egg until smooth. Stir in the cheddar cheese, then fold this mixture through the macaroni until well combined.
  6. Tip into the prepared baking dish and press down firmly so it bakes up in neat slices. Bake for 25 to 30 minutes until set and golden on top, with only a slight wobble in the centre.
  7. Rest for 10 minutes so the pie firms up. Slice into squares and serve hot.

Made this recipe? Rate it — a comment is optional.

Recipe notes

Serving suggestions

This recipe pairs well with:

Caribbean stews

Tips

  • For clean slices, press the macaroni firmly into the dish before baking and let it rest for the full 10 minutes after it comes out of the oven.
  • If the top is browning too quickly before the centre is set, loosely cover the dish and continue baking until firm.

Substitutions

  • Replace Cheddar cheese with Gruyere cheese for a nuttier, more savoury finish.
  • Replace Dijon mustard with Whole-grain mustard for a milder heat and a coarser texture.

Storage

  • Refrigerate up to 3 days
  • Cool completely, then refrigerate in a sealed container. Reheat slices in a 180°C (355°F) oven for 12 to 15 minutes until piping hot; freeze well-wrapped slices for up to 2 months and reheat from thawed.

Ratings & reviews

Liked this recipe? Share your feedback to support our cooking community.

Tried this recipe?

Choose 1–5 stars. A comment is optional.

If you leave a comment, use 10–500 characters.

Stay inspired

Discover new recipes, seasonal favourites and cooking inspiration every day. Follow JustRecipes on Pinterest and Spillt.

Recipe overview

  • Servings: 4 servings
  • Total time: 55min (20min active)
  • Difficulty: Easy
  • Cuisine: Caribbean
  • Allergens:
    Eggs Gluten Milk Wheat
Beginner friendly With serving suggestions Freezer friendly Kid friendly

Plan your meals and get a complete grocery list automatically.

Add to meal planner

Equipment you'll need

Advertisement

Recommended tools for this recipe

Best overall

WMF Mini Saucepan 16 cm with Lid

Compact stainless steel saucepan
  • High-quality stainless steel
  • Even heat distribution
  • Higher price point

Got ingredients left?

Find recipes using ingredients from this recipe or what you already have at home.

Find recipes with these ingredients →

Make this recipe easier next time

Advertisement

These tools help you get better results with less effort.

Best overall

WMF Mini Saucepan 16 cm with Lid

Compact stainless steel saucepan
  • High-quality stainless steel
  • Even heat distribution
  • Higher price point
Best value

T-fal Specialty Nonstick Handy Pot with Glass Lid 3 Quart

Affordable nonstick saucepan
  • Easy food release
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Not induction compatible
Top quality

All-Clad Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Saucepan

Professional-grade tri-ply saucepan
  • Excellent heat control
  • Premium build quality
  • Expensive

Browse alphabetically

Looking for a specific recipe? Choose a letter below to jump directly to recipes starting with that letter or number.

Enjoy cooking with JustRecipes?

Add JustRecipes as one of your preferred Google sources to discover our recipes more easily across Google Search.

Add JustRecipes to Google

Every recipe on JustRecipes follows the same structured editorial process. Learn how recipes are created, validated, translated, illustrated, and continuously improved across the platform. How we create recipes.